Início cultura Against performative listening

Against performative listening

26
0

Florian Cramer: Your book begins with darkness, in an art installation, where you can't see anything. You write that you went there to practice paying attention. At the same time, outside in the daylight, listening has become fashionable: you describe how politicians go on listening tours, managers take listening courses, media outlets apologize for not listening. And clearly, you don't trust this. So how can you tell real listening from fake listening?

Miriam Rasch: I use the term ‘performative listening' to describe a form of fake listening. Initially, I noticed a lot of this type of listening. Everyone was talking about listening everywhere: politicians, artists, leftists, rightists – all kinds of people. There was a hidden promise that, once you started listening, something would change for the better. The promise is almost more important than the actual listening, as if the promise fulfils itself. That's when it becomes a performance. Perhaps my initial question came from a distrust in this performative listening, which seems fake. This raises the question: What is real listening?

Florian Cramer: What are the most important criteria for distinguishing performative listening from actual listening?

Miriam Rasch: The most important criterion, I would say, is that in ‘real' listening you don't have a predetermined goal that you want to accomplish through listening. In performative listening, you set out to achieve something – something good, ethical, beneficial, for the love of society and other people. Real listening, I think, is not having such a goal, and accepting that you might not reach any goal, or that you might discover terrible things, or that relationships may end.

Florian Cramer: You started writing the book during the pandemic, crowdsourcing parts of it by writing down listening-related references every day and asking strangers online for suggestions. Was that the method? Did people send you suggestions that you would never have found on your own? Because this was practically a listening exercise itself, wasn't it?

Miriam Rasch: Yes. When I wanted to dive deeper into the subject of listening, I decided that I also needed to use listening as a method to do so. It's interesting to adopt a practical method like that to philosophical writing. It seemed strange to me to write a book by just sitting alone in my room and writing down all of these things that I found about listening – which is basically one-way communication, sending without receiving. That was really the start of it. I thought, ‘I'm going to listen to people.'

During the lockdowns, I basically asked an open question and had no restrictions concerning the contributions. One person gave me a quote from a book by Jordan Peterson. I would never have considered that on my own. In fact, that's how I ended up reading Carl Rogers. It was through this person who sent me a picture of a page from a Jordan Peterson book. This experience taught me that if you want to listen, you can't put restrictions up front; you need to listen to everything that comes your way. Afterwards you can try to form an opinion, but you shouldn't start with that.

Florian Cramer: Would you also listen if it's not Jordan Peterson but a racist at the dinner table? Or would you eventually say, ‘enough is enough'?

Miriam Rasch: I think that is one of the book's main themes, and one of the things that I kept coming up against: Where do you draw the line? When do you stop listening? One of the most profound insights I gained is just three words: listening isn't obeying. It often seems that listening to someone means agreeing with them, confirming them, or letting them further their message. This is true in the media context. The idea of the media listening to underrepresented groups has turned, I think, into having the most racist, vile messages being furthered in the name of listening. However, it's different when a person listens to another person.

Of course, I don't listen to everything; I also have my limits. But I really try not to draw the line beforehand but rather come up against it through practice. That's hard, and can be unpleasant, and sometimes really emotional – like with the proverbial racist uncle at the dinner table. In fact, there are always more people at that table, and one person who dominates the conversation. The others try to respond first, but then they zone out or say ‘we don't talk politics here', or something similar. However, I think listening should happen one-on-one in this case. You sit down with the uncle, away from the group of people that he can dominate. I had long conversations with people who might become racist uncles, trying to hold out for as long as possible.

The point of listening is neither arguing, nor agreeing. The issue of the racist uncle is always framed in terms of debate: How do you argue with someone like that? What do you say? How can you convince them? How do you keep things polite? It's about speaking. In fact, reading and listening to all of my sources, I noticed that 90% of them are actually about speaking. It's so easy to fall back into the mode of speaking. One of my goals really was to hold on to listening, to stop myself from arguing, and to see where I should draw the line, where I really can't handle it anymore and just walk away or say, ‘this is where we stop'. It might be farther away than you thought.

Florian Cramer: In the opening pages of the book, you cite Dutch decolonial thinker Rolando Vázquez Melken, who wrote that ‘listening is relational'. However, I found it refreshing that you are sceptical of dialogue as a cure-all. You give the example of a ‘Day of the Dialogue' event in Rotterdam, which was meant to foster intercultural understanding. You analyse how dialogue doesn't work as a kind of healing instrument or cure, at least not when the purpose is predetermined.

Miriam Rasch: Because then it becomes performative. Of course, I don't want to dismiss the wonderful initiatives related to dialogue and intercultural exchange. It's very important that we meet and talk with each other, and that facilities are available for that purpose. But there are two issues. First, as mentioned, much of the research on listening has to do with dialogue, which is actually about speaking. Therefore, if you want to learn more about listening, I think we need to turn elsewhere. Second, there is the idea that dialogue cures polarization and societal unravelling. Well, if that were true, we wouldn't be in our current situation, would we?

Florian Cramer: But isn't your book very likely to be picked up by people who want to deal with polarization? What can listening do for a divided society if we are not allowed to use it for the purpose of reducing polarization?

Miriam Rasch: Yes, it's for them. I worry about polarization too. When people say there's no such thing as polarization, I think, ‘well, I'm experiencing it'. I suppose that's why, ultimately, this is a very personal search for me. I can't stop or cure polarization on my own, but I want to at least find a better way of being in a polarized society, or a society I experience as polarized. But if listening was an easy cure, then at one point we would be done and all be happy together. Listening takes time, and needs tobe practised over and over again. Then it might have a more indirect effect. I've found that listening practice makes you more attentive and more receptive to the outside world, which may reduce polarization as a side effect.

Florian Cramer: This brings me to another point. You adopt the idea from Dori Laub's Holocaust psychiatry that a trauma witness doesn't know their own truth, and that the listener must suspend their demand for truth. You then extend this idea to the news, even to the court case of Johnny Depp. But in an age of massive, industrial-scale disinformation, isn't suspending the truth precisely what the propagandists want us to do? Could listening then become complicity?

Miriam Rasch: Yes, I see what you mean. It's like flooding the zone with shit. Well, I would never say that you need to listen to everything, and I would advise against it. But the whole point of being attentive to listening, is to make us aware that we are otherwise always rather in the sending mode. Even with fake news, slop and propaganda, it doesn't help to try and correct the fake news all the time, or pose your own truth against it. It's of no use to go into debate with the zone of shit. I also like the idea of the medium as a thing through which something can flow, rather than just being received or sent. The listener can be conceived as a medium that is attuned and interpretative but doesn't push back all the time.

Florian Cramer: I think this is where the book ties in with your background in media theory and internet criticism, because there's also something of a love letter to the early web in it: the blog that opened doors for minorities, or for the introverted writer. But, in the same section, you also write that this was partly a myth. If that past wasn't ideal either, what has actually been lost?

Miriam Rasch: Well, even if that period wasn't ideal, it doesn't mean that our current situation isn't much worse. Those two things can be true at the same time. I was lucky that, back in my day, the Internet was more about writing. Now, it's all about creating videos, using imagery, etc. I wouldn't be very good at that. I'm aware that this is nostalgia from today's middle-aged generation.

Florian Cramer: But in contrast to nostalgia, you also voice scepticism, especially regarding AI, big data and voice assistants. In your book, you argue that it is data processing, not listening. But after you completed the book, the technology progressed rapidly. Nowadays millions of people confide in AI chatbots that seem to listen to them; they never interrupt, they never make it about themselves. According to your own criteria, aren't these machines the ideal listener, and even better so than humans?

Miriam Rasch: Well, if the primary criterion of ‘real listening' is purposelessness, then I don't think that applies to chatbots. There's always a purpose. They're there to answer questions, which is why they're so useful to so many people in so many situations. And even when you have received an answer, they will ask you a new question that they can answer, such as: ‘Do you want me to help you with this and this now?' They also like talking about themselves a lot.

Florian Cramer: But doesn't something similar also exist in your own concept of listening? You make a very original point in the book: namely that we're always being told to put ourselves in other people's shoes, as a default way of listening. You argue the opposite, saying that it's about helping the other person stand in their own shoes first, helping them understand themselves before trying to understand them. But isn't that a purpose?

Miriam Rasch: Maybe it's a purpose, but it's an empty purpose. Because I don't know what will happen to you if I help you achieve some insight about yourself by listening to you. I don't know what this insight will be. I can't steer it. I have no control over it. I don't know if it's true. The only thing I can hope for is that, because I am there for you to speak to, something will happen.

Florian Cramer: How can we imagine this working in practice? Putting other people into their own shoes: How would it work at the kitchen table, or in a classroom, or in any other social situation? Could you give an example of that?

Miriam Rasch: I always say that the first step to being a good listener is to shut up. And that's really, really hard. So that's already a super interesting exercise in itself. You can do it at the kitchen table, by responding only through body language – nodding, smiling or looking puzzled – while the other person continues talking beyond the point at which you would normally give your opinion or ask a question. The questions we ask are very often leading. A person in a listening role also often brings the story back to themselves: ‘I've experienced that too'; ‘Oh, but did you know, did you read, did you see…?' I would say that the first step is really holding the space for the other person to talk.

Florian Cramer: In your book you go even further: you listen to human conversations, to experimental music, chickens, the sea, and finally, via Wisława Szymborska's poem Conversation with a Stone, to a stone that says that it doesn't have a door. Now, playing the devil's advocate, I would argue that the word ‘listening' is doing an awful lot of work here. What do we gain by calling paying attention to nature ‘listening,' rather than just calling it attention?

Miriam Rasch: That's a really good question. The subtitle of the original Dutch book is ‘Attention and Receptivity'. I would say that attention is a very important part of listening but not the only part. And that's something I only realized very late in the process, perhaps even after completing the book: that it was really about turning the communication model on its head. In communication, we're so focused on sending and not receiving. Listening is usually only understood as receiving. I believe that paying attention, and thus, listening, is a form of sending, because you're sending your attention somewhere. It's an outward energy. But there's another side to the relationship as well: the inward energy, the receptivity. If you try to listen to nature, for example, you're paying attention to it. But how do you receive that? For me, listening to nature is an exercise in finding out how to become a good listener in our society. I truly think that listening to the non-verbal is important training for listening to the verbal, including people and their opinions.

Florian Cramer: But to what extent can listening also involve silence? Perhaps I can confront you with one point in the book where I take issue: your discussion about noise-cancelling headphones. My critical perspective stems from a current research project on neurodivergence and neuroinclusivity that I co-initiated. Noise-cancelling headphones are widely used in neurodivergent communities, particularly among people on the autism and ADHD spectrums, to prevent burnout and sensory overload. In your book, you refer to these devices as ‘orphic tools' for sealing off one's ears. And you call it a moral problem, not just a technological one. At the same time, however, you are very careful not to be techno-skeptical, and you highlight many positive examples, such as the beneficial role of podcasts, the #MeToo movement, phone recordings connecting you to birds. But what is the difference then? If technology helps us to listen, what is then the moral issue with technology that creates silence?

Miriam Rasch: This is interesting, because my whole point about noise cancelling is intended to provoke. People get very angry about it, which itself suggests a moral dimension. I started thinking about noise cancellation when I was on a residency in Amsterdam, writing the book. I was in an apartment for expats, on the outskirts of the city, in a very new housing block, filled with twenty- and thirty-somethings – expats with good jobs. From my window, I could see the block opposite and all its windows. It was like Hitchcock's Rear Window, because I could see all those people in their own apartments, and they were all wearing these huge headphones. This was such a strange sight. What was going on there? I think they were escaping into their own bubble of sound. For me, this is connected to the ubiquity of wireless earbuds. They've been around for about ten years, and now people keep them in even when they're talking to you. I find that so strange. What is that? Are you afraid to talk to me properly?

Florian Cramer: I am reminded of the Dutch Fluxus artist Willem de Ridder who used the Walkman – the first device with mobile headphones – for use in psychogeographic city tours and storytelling in the early 1980s. His Walkman audio tours were listening exercises, too. Can't you be a good listener with headphones?

Miriam Rasch: Of course. But once putting on your headphones becomes an automatic behaviour every time you step out of the door, or even when you're in your own apartment, something is happening. I've described listening as an act of receiving. With headphones, you are receiving something, but you take control over what you receive. The question is: What does it imply if you can walk out into the street or a public space and shut yourself off from it, at least with one of your senses? Perhaps some people desperately need to do that, but I'm pretty sure many people who use headphones don't need to. The use of technology always extends beyond its original purpose and impacts relational settings.

Florian Cramer: Isn't listening to nothing also a form of listening? I understand that it ties into the concept of receptive generosity, and perhaps you would argue that it is not a generous way of listening.

Miriam Rasch: It can be very generous to yourself, to give yourself the attention that headphones offer, or the peace of mind. It can be a form of self-care, I would say, which can be very generous.

Florian Cramer: The Dutch title of your book, Luisteroefeningen, means ‘listening exercises', but it has all kinds of semantic layers that are difficult to translate into English. Although the Dutch word is linguistically related to the English word ‘listening', it also has the connotation of obeying or following orders.

Miriam Rasch: Yes, many people feel a certain resistance to the notion of listening because it's associated precisely with obedience, like in school. The teacher who wants everyone to be quiet or the parent who raises their finger and says, ‘Listen to me!' It means you're subordinate and not supposed to speak your mind. I think we sometimes cling a bit too much to the idea that listening equals agreement. We should emancipate listening from that idea.

Florian Cramer: If I were to consider the dark side of listening, I would think of the early days of the radio medium as a propaganda tool. For example, during the Third Reich, radios were subsidized by the state, so that everyone could listen to Hitler's speeches. Or consider the EMI logo featuring the dog listening to the gramophone as ‘His Master's Voice'.

Miriam Rasch: This relates to the old-fashioned communication model, whereby someone sends a message that is injected directly, via the ear, into the listener's mind. Somehow we still adhere to this model, despite the fact that the Internet and pirate media turned this logic upside down in the late twentieth century. Listening is no longer a one-way street.

Florian Cramer: If we take the concept of listening theorized and practised by Pauline Oliveros, to whom you refer throughout your book, it could be called a mindful form of listening. I have no trouble imagining someone creating a fascist form of mindful listening. We've already seen this happening in religious cults, for example.

Miriam Rasch: And listening to nature, listening to your body, listening to your intuition – all of these things are also prone to radicalization.

Florian Cramer: Like during the COVID-19 pandemic, when many esoteric deniers said: ‘I don't want the vaccine because I can listen to my body myself.'

Miriam Rasch: ‘And my intuition tells me what is good for me.' So, yes, there's definitely this dark side to listening, which you can find in many places. But, again, this is a type of listening with a clear purpose and a predetermined answer. It's listening to confirm. The same thing happens when talking to people, when you listen in the hope that you'll hear what you want to hear. I think the same is the case with more radical, right-wing spiritualist forms of listening. Or with people who claim they can listen to nature and know exactly what the trees want. Once again, it's rather a kind of speaking.

Florian Cramer: Isn't the problem not only speaking but also passivity? If you argue that listening is the ethically good way of being in the world, then this can also be exploited as a form of complacency.

Miriam Rasch: Well, it's very difficult to contradict someone who says, ‘I'm listening to my own body, and it's telling me to do this and that.' What can you say? ‘You're not hearing correctly'? – you can't argue with it. Philosophers like to say that you have to bracket your prejudices. That's true but also impossible. For good listening, first you need to understand them in order to be able to set them aside. And this is what often happens when you listen to nature or your body: a lot of prejudice comes to the surface.

Florian Cramer: Are receptive generosity and relational listening enough? Isn't critical listening also needed? This seems to clash with your approach of suspending disbelief.

Miriam Rasch: I would argue that the criticality should follow after the suspension. I've tried to be radical in upholding the open and empty listening space, because starting from a critical position brings certain presuppositions with it. However, this doesn't mean that criticality can't be introduced at a later stage, or that you can't form your own opinion, or that you can't contradict someone, or that you can't be angry with someone – all of these things can still happen. The challenge is to listen quietly for 15 minutes, and reserve your opinion until afterwards.

Florian Cramer: But in order to be able to listen without prejudices, you first need to cancel your prejudices, right? And this a critical endeavour. So, in that sense, it's also a priori, not just a posteriori.

Miriam Rasch: It is criticality towards yourself, not towards the other. At least initially.

Florian Cramer: There's a quote in your book that I found really funny: at some point you admit that you are not usually very interested in other people's opinions. So through all this – the chickens, the stone that wouldn't talk to you – have you become a better listener?

Miriam Rasch: I wasn't a very good listener. That was one of the reasons why I wanted to learn. I had this hunch that becoming a better listener would somehow be good for me: perhaps not making me a better person but giving me something valuable. Not so much because I wanted to listen to other people's opinions, that's true. People have opinions about everything, including things they don't know anything about. I'm also not interested in my own opinions about everything either, and I try not to have them. But sometimes I felt insecure and thought that maybe I should.

Listening is the practice of holding back opinions. And I do think I've become a better listener. Ultimately, this is because of the practice of listening to the nonverbal. You can then apply this to listening to other people and their opinions – it shouldn't be the other way around. When it comes to listening, people tend to start at the highest level, for example, that a leftist should listen to a radical rightist, or vice versa. But no one should start there. I think you should just start by, indeed, taking off your headphones when you're in the woods and listening to the sounds that the different leaves make when they rustle in the wind – which can be really, really hard, but at least it's not emotionally provocative. When you practise this kind of listening, it becomes easier to listen to other people.

 

Florian Cramer interviewed Miriam for Eurozine in September 2026.